RE: mothball smell to whole belly clams

From: Jon McGraw (JonMcGraw@seafreeze.com)
Date: Thu Jul 24 2003 - 12:21:29 PDT

  • Next message: howgate: "Re: Risks from raw Scomber scrombus consumption?"

    Hello All,

    Reports such as these cause me to question whether we can ever get food
    safety education across
    to the consuming public. The human race has been given the marvelous gift
    combination of taste, smell, AND the intellect to appreciate the sublime and
    REJECT the abnormal. I don't care how good my dog can smell, that grin on
    his face, after a particularly loathsome repast, says it all. Why, oh why,
    would anyone continue to eat shellfish that tastes like mothballs????!!!!

    Jon McGraw
    Seafreeze
    Seattle, WA

    -----Original Message-----
    From: George Chang [mailto:gwchang@uclink4.berkeley.edu]
    Sent: Thursday, July 24, 2003 11:54 AM
    To: nancy.balcom@uconn.edu
    Cc: seafood@ucdavis.edu
    Subject: Re: mothball smell to whole belly clams

    Nancy Balcom writes...

    >I was contacted by someone with our state health department who
    >was following up on a consumer complaint. The person and a
    >companion ordered and ate orders of deep fried, breaded, whole
    >belly clams, prepared on site. The person in question ate two that
    >tasted (or smelled, perhaps) in his words, like "mothballs" or
    >camphor....
    >
    >Has anyone ever run across this before or have any ideas of what
    >might have caused this smell/taste in the clams?

    Hi Nancy,

            I haven't heard of mothball-tasting clams, but your account
    reminds me of what happened some decades ago in the small college
    town where I grew up. A batch of chicken feed got contaminated with
    mothballs or the like. The eggs were said to have tasted terrible.
    I never had any, but our neighbor, the poultry science professor,
    said that they tasted just like mothballs!

            Again, this may or may not have any relevance to your
    consumer's complaint.

    Best regards,
    George Chang
    Univ of Calif, Berkeley



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Jul 24 2003 - 12:26:57 PDT