[LAW-LIB:55225] DATABASES : MEDICAL: ABORTION : UNITED STATES: GOVERNMENT : CENSORSHIP: The POPLINE Situation

From: David P. Dillard (jwne@temple.edu)
Date: Fri Apr 04 2008 - 11:57:23 PDT

  • Next message: Barker, Anne: "[LAW-LIB:55226] RE: DATABASES : MEDICAL: ABORTION : UNITED STATES: GOVERNMENT : CENSORSHIP: The POPLINE Situation"

    DATABASES :
    MEDICAL: ABORTION :
    UNITED STATES: GOVERNMENT :
    CENSORSHIP:
    The POPLINE Situation

    Media attention to this development, abortion as a subject term not being
    searchable, is now growing. There are articles about this situation in
    the following sources:

    Government Bans the Word "Abortion"
    Village Voice, NY - 5 hours ago
    Type the word in the search engine for Popline, the huge, database that
    the federal government bills as "your connection to the world's
    reproductive health ...
    Word "abortion" disappears from US government-funded search engine

    Inquirer, UK - 1 hour ago
    The site, Popline, which is administered by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg
    School of Public Health in Maryland, recently got a grant from USAID, the
    Agency for ...

    Johns Hopkins University Criticized for Blocking Abortion Search ...
    LifeNews.com
    Government Funded Health Search Engine Blocks 'Abortion' Wired News
    Johns Hopkins U. Health Database Blocks Searches for 'Abortion' Chronicle
    of Higher Education (subscription)
    all 5 news articles

    Government Database Restricting Information On Abortion
    The Experiment - Apr 3, 2008
    Yesterday I saw a posting on the Progressive Librarian Guild list stating
    that the word abortion was now a stop word on POPLINE, a database of the
    ...
    A is for abortion, but doesn't have the same meaning as it

    Feministing, NY - 5 hours ago
    As a project of Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, POPLINE
    receives its funding from USAID. We have the history there. ...
    Your Search for "Abortion" Yields Nothing
    RH Reality Check, DC - 23 hours ago
    It seems the POPLINE database, defined as "the world's largest database on
    reproductive health (emphasis mine), containing citations with abstracts
    to ...

    Johns Hopkins Bows To USAID Censorship Push
    Slashdot - 1 hour ago
    An anonymous reader sends us to Wired's Threat Level blog for news that
    the federally funded Popline database at Johns Hopkins University, said to
    be the ...

    It is not listed in the above result from Google News, but a Google Alert
    indicates that there is also an article in the Chronicle of Higher
    Education, so it is not just librarians concerned about this issue any
    longer. I also want to personally thank Gary Price for including this
    development in ResourceShelf and also I would like to thank all of the
    librarians who have posted to lists they are members of regarding this.

    So much for the media. It gets very interesting in Google:

    Results 1 - 10 of about 607,000 for popline and abortion.

    <http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&rls=GGLD%2CGGLD%3A2005-
    17%2CGGLD%3Aen&q=popline+and+abortion&btnG=Search>

    A shorter URL for the above link:

    <http://tinyurl.com/5ggayg>

    But this is not about quantity, it is the "quality" of the hits at the
    top of this search deck:

    Crooks and Liars POPLINE restricts the word Abortion from the ...Yes we
    did make a change in POPLINE. We recently made all abortion terms stop
    words. As a federally funded project, we decided this was best for now.
    ...
    www.crooksandliars.com/2008/04/03/popline-restricts-the-word-
    abortion-from-the-government-funded-database/
    - 17 hours ago - Similar pages

    U.S. Funded Health Search Engine Blocks 'Abortion' | Threat Level
    ...Called Popline, the search site is run by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg
    School ... But on Thursday, a search on "abortion" was producing only the
    message "No ...
    blog.wired.com/27bstroke6/2008/04/a-government-fu.html - 19 hours ago -
    Similar pages

    "Abortion" scrapped as research descriptor on POPLINE (govt-spons
    ..."Abortion" scrapped as research descriptor on POPLINE (govt-spons.
    database)
    www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/
    duboard.php?az=view_all&address=389x3103735
    - 9 hours ago - Similar pages

    Radio Left :: POPLINE restricts the word Abortion from the ...Radio Left.
    Now in our 6th year driving the right-wing nuts. Internet talk radio for
    liberals and Democrats with a liberal blogging community to express ...
    blog.radioleft.com/blog/_archives/2008/4/3/3619432.html - 15 hours ago -
    Similar pages

    Abortion? No such thing Feminist Philosophersentering abortion as a
    search term in the POPLINE database now returns zero ... It is now
    impossible to get a decent search of POPLINE using abortion as ...
    feministphilosophers.wordpress.com/2008/04/04/abortion-no-such-thing/ - 9
    hours ago - Similar pages

    infomusings on LIS, grad school, academia, and other random thingsIf you
    do a subject keyword search in POPLINE for abortion, the result is:. No
    records found by latest query. If you do a subject keyword search in
    POPLINE ...
    blog.infomuse.net/ - Similar pages

    Truth Feeds : POPLINE restricts the word ?Abortion? from the ...POPLINE
    restricts the word ?Abortion? from the government funded database
    BREAKING: Another KBR Rape Case Douglas Feith: Iraq was not a retaliation
    for ...
    truthfeeds.com/Daily-News/72160/
    POPLINE-restricts-the-word-Abortion-from-the-government-funded-database
    - 15 hours ago - Similar pages

    The Galloping BeaverThis, despite the fact that Popline has a library
    brimming with articles and peer reviewed papers on abortion. Popline has
    blocked search access to over ...
    thegallopingbeaver.blogspot.com/ - Similar pages

    Popline blocking searches for abortion resources SpinstahPopline blocking
    searches for abortion resources. April 4, 2008 by Alison. Popline, which I
    previously hadnt heard of, bills itself as Your connection to ...
    ramblingon.wordpress.com/2008/04/04/
    popline-blocking-searches-for-abortion-resources/
    - 3 hours ago - Similar pages

    Why is a Government-Funded Reproductive Health Database Blocking ...Today
    through medical librarian channels, I got word that entering abortion as a
    search term in the POPLINE database now returns zero results because of a
    ...
    womenshealthnews.wordpress.com/.../ - Similar pages

    POPLINE Keyword Guide -- Main Index ABORTIONPOPLINE Keyword Guide -- Main
    Index << ABDOMINAL CRAMPS | ABORTION ... ABORTION. Scope Note: Removal of
    a fetus from the uterus by any of a number of ...
    db.jhuccp.org/ICS-WPD/POPWEB/Thesaurus/tr7.htm - 5k - Cached - Similar
    pages

    POPLINE Keyword Guide -- Main Index ABORTION, SPONTANEOUSPOPLINE Keyword
    Guide -- Main Index. << ABORTION, HABITUAL | ABORTION, SPONTANEOUS |
    ABSTINENCE >>. Back to: "A". ABORTION, SPONTANEOUS ...
    db.jhuccp.org/ICS-WPD/POPWEB/Thesaurus/tr40.htm - 5k - Cached - Similar
    pages
    More results from db.jhuccp.org

    Spontaneous abortion and induced abortion: an adjustment for the
    ...POPLINE Document Number: 015013. Author(s):. Susser E. Source citation:
    ... 2 different ratios have been used to represent the spontaneous
    abortion rate in ...
    www.popline.org/docs/0568/015013.html - 4k - Cached - Similar pages

    Inmagic CS/WebPublisher PRO found 1 recordsNew Basic Search | New Advanced
    Search | POPLINE Document Delivery Policy ... Abstract: In Kenya, where
    abortion is permitted only to save a woman's life, ...
    www.popline.org/docs/126980 - 28k - Cached - Similar pages
    More results from www.popline.org

    Your Search for "Abortion" Yields Nothing | Reproductive Health
    ...POPLINE's explanation is utterly insufficient. Abortion is a medical
    term for a legal procedure. Politics has absolutely no place in the
    medical database of ...
    www.rhrealitycheck.org/blog/2008/04/03/your-search-for-abortion-yields-nothing
    - 52k - 23 hours ago - Cached - Similar pages

    The Experiment Blog Archive Government Database Restricting ...Yesterday
    I saw a posting on the Progressive Librarian Guild list stating that the
    word abortion was now a stop word on POPLINE, a database of the ...
    www.theexperiment.org/?p=2275 - 19k - Cached - Similar pages

    UNITED STATES: GOVERNMENT : DATABASES : DEMOGRAPHY: ISSUES ...Librarian
    Guild list stating that the word abortion was now a stop word* on POPLINE,
    a database of the Worlds reproductive health literature This ...
    groups.google.com/group/Educator-Gold/browse_thread/thread/987f7f83c8e1e2ca
    - 51k - 19 hours ago - Cached - Similar pages

    We read banned books, and other stuff tooPOPLINE has recently decided to
    make all abortion words stop words. This means that someone searching the
    POPLINE database for abortion or abortions or ...
    bclaifc.wordpress.com/ - 45k - Cached - Similar pages

    ResourceShelf The POPLINE StoryBtw, you can still find entries (nearly
    25000) that deal with abortion issues ... being used with the POPLINE
    database we have found it a challenge to use. ...
    www.resourceshelf.com/2008/04/04/the-popline-story - 33k - 20 hours ago -
    Cached - Similar pages

    Antibiotic prophylaxis for medical and surgical first-trimester ...of both
    strategies for first-trimester abortion. We will conduct. computerized
    searches of PubMed, EMBASE, POPLINE,. 2. Antibiotic prophylaxis for
    medical ...
    doi.wiley.com/10.1002/14651858.CD005217 - Similar pages

    In addition to the other records mostly about the gag on searches of
    abortion, there is this record above:

    Spontaneous abortion and induced abortion: an adjustment for the
    ...POPLINE Document Number: 015013. Author(s):. Susser E. Source citation:
    ... 2 different ratios have been used to represent the spontaneous
    abortion rate in ...
    www.popline.org/docs/0568/015013.html - 4k - Cached - Similar pages

    This is an actual document in the POPLINE database about abortion that is
    indexed by Google. This may indicate along with the high posting of
    results in Google for POPLINE and abortion, that while POPLINE has not
    been letting users search the subject term abortion in POPLINE, Google has
    absolutely no problem letting Google users know where to find abortion in
    the POPLINE database.

    The Google link for this listing takes the user to this POPLINE record:

    Title: Spontaneous abortion and induced abortion: an adjustment for the
    presence of induced abortion when estimating the rate of spontaneous
    abortion from cross-sectional studies.

    POPLINE Document Number: 015013

    Author(s):

    Susser E

    Source citation:

    American Journal of Epidemiology, 1983 Mar;117(3):305-8.

    Abstract:

    High rates of induced abortion in a population may distort currently
    employed measures of the rate of spontaneous abortion. 2 different ratios
    have been used to represent the spontaneous abortion rate in
    cross-sectional studies of populations with high rates of induced
    abortion. The numerator in both is the number of spontaneous abortions,
    while the denominator of 1 is the number of spontaneous abortions plus the
    number of births after 28 weeks. The denominator of the other adds the
    number of induced abortions to this sum. Variations in the frequency and
    patterns of induced abortions influence both measures. Inflation of the
    1st ratio will be greatest in a population where women undergo induced
    abortion of late gestations but abort spontaneously at early gestations,
    while the 2nd ratio will be most seriously diminished when women elect
    induced abortion at early gestations but abort spontaneously at a late
    stage. The simplified estimate of the "true" rate (STR) of spontaneous
    abortion is a simple and convenient statistic that offers a good estimate.
    The numerator of the STR is the number of spontaneous abortions while the
    denominator is the sum of the number of spontaneous abortions, the number
    of live and stillbirths after 28 weeks, and 1/2 the number of induced
    abortions. The simplified estimate generally yields a result close to the
    "true" spontaneous abortion rate, because induced abortions are
    concentrated during the same period of gestation as spontaneous abortions;
    as a result, on average induced abortions represent pregnancies that
    survived approximately 1/2 the risk for spontaneous abortion that a live
    birth survived. The simplified equation can be modified if discrepancies
    are found on applying the full procedure for estimating the true rate.

    Keywords:

    Abortion
    Abortion, Spontaneous
    Abortion Rate
    Vital Statistics
    Estimation Technics
    Data Analysis
    Fertility Control, Postconception
    Family Planning
    Pregnancy Complications
    Diseases
    Population Statistics
    Research Methodology

    Index page

    ------------------------------

    There is also an interesting development with the POPLINE database.

    Somebody emailed me and told me that they were able to get a result from
    the POPLINE database from a search of the full word abortion. I tried the
    same search upon reading the message but got the same error message at
    that time, a couple of hours or so ago, that we all have been getting. I
    therefore discounted that message as nothing more than a transient glitch
    in the POPLINE blocking system. Now however I am getting a search result
    for a search of the word abortion. Twenty minutes or so ago, before I
    started this message the result was 187 records. I just tried again and
    the result is now over 500 records so this may be an indication that the
    records are being rebuilt into the system as indexed by subject under that
    search term, abortion. The bottom line is that the concern expressed by
    so many librarians and now followed by so many in other fields including
    journalists in various publications may have caused the folks at John
    Hopkins to abort the gag on the search of abortion. This result, if that
    is a correct interpretation of these observations, was achieved without
    any newspaper, television or other mass media sources reporting this
    development as far as I am aware of.

    [Just tried the search again before sending this message and the result
    total for the same search is now 1094 records.]

    I hope you all have a great weekend.

    ==============================================

    Previous Net-Gold Posts Regarding POPLINE

    UNITED STATES: GOVERNMENT :
    DATABASES :
    DEMOGRAPHY: ISSUES :
    MEDICAL: ABORTION:
    Government Database Restricting Information On Abortion
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Net-Gold/message/22980>

    UNITED STATES: GOVERNMENT :
    DATABASES :
    DEMOGRAPHY: ISSUES :
    MEDICAL: ABORTION :
    CENSORSHIP:
    U.S. Funded Health Search Engine Blocks 'Abortion'
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Net-Gold/message/22981>

    I also sent this additional message to the DIG_REF list

    Subject: Re: [DIG_REF] UNITED STATES: GOVERNMENT : DATABASES : DEMOGRAPHY:
    ISSUES : MEDICAL: ABORTION : CENSORSHIP: Government Database Restricting
    Information On Abortion
    From: "David P. Dillard" <jwne@TEMPLE.EDU>
    Date: Thu, 3 Apr 2008 22:33:17 -0400
    <http://digref.org/archive/Current/msg02142.html>

    Also of possible interest.

    COMPUTER: OPERATING SYSTEMS:
    Microsoft Will Extend Life of Windows XP--Again
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Net-Gold/message/22986>

    SEARCH ENGINES: GOOGLE ALTERNATIVES:
    Article / MORE SEARCH ENGINE RESOURCES
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Net-Gold/message/22990>

    UNITED STATES :
    POLLS:
    Poll: 81 Percent Think US on Wrong Track
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Net-Gold/message/22987>

    FOOD DRINK NUTRITION DIET: DRINK: COFFEE :
    MEDICAL: CONDITIONS: ALZHEIMER'S:
    A Coffee a Day Helps Keep the Dementia Away
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Net-Gold/message/22983>

    Again, a great weekend to all.

    Sincerely,
    David Dillard
    Temple University
    (215) 204 - 4584
    jwne@temple.edu
    Net-Gold
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/net-gold>
    <http://listserv.temple.edu/archives/net-gold.html>
    <http://groups.google.com/group/net-gold?hl=en>
    <http://net-gold.jiglu.com/>
    General Internet & Print Resources
    <http://guides.temple.edu/general-internet>
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Net-Gold/message/20309>
    <http://www.edu-cyberpg.com/ringleaders/davidd.html>
    Educator-Gold
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Educator-Gold/>
    K12ADMINLIFE
    <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/K12AdminLIFE/>
    Nina Dillard's Photographs on Net-Gold
    <http://tinyurl.com/36qd2o>
    Net-Gold Membership Required to View Photos



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Fri Apr 04 2008 - 12:00:31 PDT