This really irks me though. What are we supposed to do with the old sets
-- clog the landfills? I think instead publishers should treat these large
sets like buying a new car. When I go in to buy my new WFPD car, I trade
in my old set and get something back on it towards the purchase of the new
one. Then the publisher takes the trade-in and "refurbishes" with some new
tires/revised volumes, and puts it out on the "used car" lot for sale
again. I'd buy a refurbished used set to save myself the full price of a
brand new set.
"Kendall
Svengalis" To: "Mitchell, Michelle" <mmitchell@hsblawfirm.com>, law-lib@ucdavis.edu
<rilawpress@ids.n cc:
et> Subject: Re: West's 4th Practice Digest
Sent by:
owner-law-lib@ucd
avis.edu
03/02/2004 01:10
PM
Michelle's certainly got the right idea. The cost of Federal Practice
Digest is $4,980.50 to buy new. The supplements (pocket parts and revised
vols.) cost $4,747.00 in 2003, up from $4,142.00 in 2002. Buying a new set
every 13 months puts you over the cost divide. Buying a new set every two
years saves your library $4,513.50 every two-year cycle (assuming supp.
costs remain the same, which, of course, they won't). Here's the track
record of the past few years:
Federal Practice Digest 4th
1998: $1,968.50
1999: $2,234.00
2000: $2,547.00
2001: $3,564.75
2002: $4,142.00
2003: $4,747.00
That's a 141% increase over five years, with 1998 as the base year.
Canceling and re-purchasing this set makes prefect sense under these
circumstances, particularly for the library which would otherwise have to
drop the subscription entirely.
Ken Svengalis
Rhode Island Law Press
Publishers of the Legal Information
Buyer's Guide & Reference Manual
204 Wyassup Road
N. Stonington, CT 06359
(860) 535-0362
rilawpress@ids.net
> I just figured up how much it would cost me to buy a new set versus
> continuing the updates. I am sure you know where I am going here. It
costs
> less for a new set then to update it (based on the yearly price of
updates).
> This set may go the same way as AmJur and CJS - we buy a new set only
every
> three years and then in a staggered order so we don't incur all the cost
at
> once.
>
> Michelle I. Mitchell
> Library Services Coordinator
> Haynsworth Sinkler Boyd, P.A.
> 1201 Main St Suite 2200
> Columbia, SC 29201
> Phone: 803.540.7858
> Fax: 803.765.1243
> mmitchell@hsblawfirm.com
>
> All opinions are my own and do not reflect the view of my employer.
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Marie Erickson [mailto:MErickson@LASC.ORG]
> Sent: Monday, March 01, 2004 5:24 PM
> To: Jill Henderson; law-lib@ucdavis.edu
> Subject: RE: West's 4th Practice Digest
>
>
> West just redid the civil rights key numbers.
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Jill Henderson [mailto:hendersj@taylorcountytexas.org]
> Sent: Monday, March 01, 2004 3:30 PM
> To: law-lib@ucdavis.edu
> Subject: West's 4th Practice Digest
>
>
> Does anyone know why West decided to reissue all of the volumes on Civil
> Rights, (namely vols. 12B throught 18A) from their West's Federal
Practice
> Digest set? This 'hit" is going to cost me over $1800.
>
> Has West lost any sense of personal responsibity toward their customers?
Do
> they not understand that small entities with limited budgets cannot
absorb
> unexpected expenditures such as this. I would try to understand if these
> volumes were decades old and all of them had stand alone pocket parts -
but
> they don't.
>
> Of these volumes:
> 2 had - 1997 copyright dates, (Vol. 14 and 14a with year 2002 stand alone
> supplements containing 527-616 pages;
> 2 had - 1999 dates (vol. 18 and 18A with 2002 pocket parts of 111-181
> pages);
> 13 had - 2001 dates with 2002 pocket parts totaling anywhere from low of
19
> pages to high of 156 pages {most are under 100 pages};
> 3 vols. had - 2002 dates (12b, 12c and 13) with 2002 pocket parts of 5 to
8
> pages.
>
> I sent back the 2003 pocket parts, but I was trying hard to show some
> loyalty to this set and not cancel thecomplete set outright. Looks like
> loyalty was not good enough for West.
>
> Jill Finley Henderson
> 300 Oak St.
> Abilene, Tx. 79606
> (V) 325-674-1395
> (F) 325-738-8601
>
>
> ------------------------------------------------------------
> The information contained in this e-mail transmittal, including any
attached
> document(s), is confidential. The information is intended only for the
use
> of the named recipient. If you are not the named recipient, you are
hereby
> notified that any use, disclosure, copying, or distribution of the
contents
> hereof is strictly prohibited.
>
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Wed Nov 14 2007 - 20:45:29 PST