[IAMSLIC:99] JSTOR vs. Print

From: Joe Wible (wible@stanford.edu)
Date: Thu May 10 2001 - 10:12:28 PDT

  • Next message: Linda Pikula: "[IAMSLIC:100] A call for nominations (fwd)"

    IAMSLIC,

    I believe there has been some discussion about whether it is possible
    to regain some valuable shelf space by removing back runs of journals
    that are available full-text through JSTOR. Below is the experience
    of one library.

    Joe

    ____________________________________

    "BAKERED!" UNM DISCARDS, THEN REACQUIRES MATH JOURNAL
    COLLECTION
    The University of New Mexico (UNM) will reacquire more than
    800 previously discarded math journals after faculty
    members at the University of New Mexico (UNM) protested
    their removal. "The journals are coming back," confirmed
    UNM library spokesperson Carolyn Gonzalez. Gonzalez says
    the UNM library initially donated a set of Applied
    Mathematics journals to an individual collector who
    salvages journals, and those will be returned. The library
    sent a second collection of journals to the University of
    Louisville and the U.S. Book Exchange, a nonprofit
    foundation which distributes materials to libraries. UNM
    library officials say those journals will not come back,
    but will be replaced by copies to be supplied by the
    research library at the Los Alamos National Laboratory.
    Those journals actually represent an upgrade for the
    library, as they are in better shape than the copies
    discarded by the UNM library. Struggling with a persistent
    space issue, the library made the decision to discard the
    journals, but reacquired them after the math faculty
    protested.

    "The information in the journals is available on JSTOR,
    which we subscribe to, but math faculty didn't find the
    material as easy to read as the print journals," says
    Gonzalez. "Unfortunately this information didn't get to the
    library. We try to be very responsive to our faculty." But
    Gonzales concedes that while the journals may be coming
    back, the problem of storing them remains. The university
    had asked the New Mexico state legislature for $10 million
    in 2001 to build a storage facility. They were
    rejected. "We are acquiring 1.5 miles of materials
    annually," Gonzalez notes, stressing the need for a storage
    facility to avert problems like the one with UNM's math
    faculty. "Our goal is to find the funding for the storage
    facility somewhere. Had we gotten that, this incident never
    would've happened. We just have to be persistent."



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu May 10 2001 - 10:17:57 PDT