[CALMAP:255] problems with finding maps/GIS in MELVYL and in an OCLC WorldCat interface by July27, please

From: Mary Larsgaard (mary@library.ucsb.edu)
Date: Tue Jul 24 2007 - 08:45:10 PDT

  • Next message: Kathy Stroud: "[CALMAP:256] Minutes for Dec 05 meeting"

    Kathy and I are members of a CDL group
    looking for major user-interface problems
    in a WorldCat interface. This is looking for
    major general-user problems, and using
    the U of Washington Libraries WorldCat
    interface to find out if the problems in finding
    hardcopy and digital cartographic materials
    still occur in MELVYL or if there are new problems.

    So ... Kathy and I would appreciate receiving your
    thoughts on major general-user problems by July 27 (this
    task force has a *very* short time line - interim
    report by July 25, final report by end of August)
    on finding Our Stuff, either on MELVYL or
    on WorldCat - please use the U of Washington
    interface if you're going to be kind to Kathy
    and me and experiment with this:-)
    http://www.lib.washington.edu/

    The following ones I've listed are just
    my favorites. Am sure I've missed obvious ones.
    I did notice in trying out the UWA interface
    that relevance sorting works quite well -
    just the normal problems (e.g., in subject
    headings state names are often abbreviated,
    not spelled out, and the likelihood of a general
    user typing in "calif" is low - and "CA" appears
    only in publisher's addresses)

    II. Maps and GIS
        a. Maps: Mary
           i. Titles are frequently generic, leading to large numbers
    of false drops, especially on the single-box search on initial screen.
           ii. Users generally need information for small areas at the
    sheet level; we catalog generally only at the series level.
        b. GIS: Kathy
           i. Users have difficulty finding digital data in online catalog.

    Any assistance is much appreciated.

    Mary

    -- 
    Mary Lynette Larsgaard
    Director, Map Library
    Assistant Head, Map and Imagery Laboratory
    Davidson Library
    University of California, Santa Barbara
    Santa Barbara CA 93106-9010
    USA
    mary@library.ucsb.edu
    voice: 805/893-4049; 2779, reference desk
    fax: 805/893-8799
    



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Tue Jul 24 2007 - 09:07:58 PDT